Why Zillow’s Zestimate Could Cost You $250K+

If you’re an apartment owner or own income-producing real estate, there’s a good chance you’ve turned to Zillow to estimate your property’s value. While Zillow can be a useful tool for single-family homes, its valuation methods often fall short for income-producing properties like multifamily buildings. Let me explain why relying solely on Zillow could cost you hundreds of thousands of dollars.


Zillow vs. Professional Valuation: The $200,000 Difference

Zillow’s algorithms are designed to estimate property values quickly and automatically, but they often fail to account for critical details unique to income-producing real estate. Over the past year, we’ve seen an average discrepancy of $200,000 or more between Zillow’s estimates and the prices we’ve achieved for our clients.

Here are some real examples:

  • 1201 Olive Avenue: Zillow estimated $760,000. We sold it for $980,000, resulting in a $219,000 difference.
  • 21 West Arbor: Zillow estimated $1,100,000. We sold it for $1,250,000, a $150,000 increase.
  • 2013 East Eighth Street in Alhambra: Zillow estimated $1,400,000. We sold it for $1,673,000, creating a $273,000 difference.

These discrepancies highlight Zillow’s inability to capture the full value of income-producing properties. Whether it’s missing critical income data or relying on incomplete property details, Zillow often leaves property owners unaware of their true asset value.

Why Zillow Falls Short for Income-Producing Properties

While Zillow can be useful for estimating values on single-family homes, its limitations become glaringly obvious when applied to multifamily or income-producing properties. Here are the key reasons why:

1. Lack of Income Data

The value of an income-producing property is directly tied to the income it generates. Investors buy multifamily properties for their income streams, not just the physical building. Zillow, however, doesn’t account for rents, vacancy rates, or income potential.

2. Incomplete Property Details

Zillow often relies on outdated or inaccurate public records. For example, it might not know that your property has additional units, extra square footage, or recent renovations, all of which significantly affect value.

3. No Consideration of Market Metrics

Professional valuations use metrics like the Gross Rent Multiplier (GRM) and Capitalization Rate (Cap Rate) to assess property value. Zillow doesn’t have the data to calculate these metrics, making its estimates incomplete.

4. Price Per Square Foot Isn’t Enough

Zillow relies heavily on price-per-square-foot calculations, but this alone doesn’t tell the full story for income-producing properties. For instance, two similar fourplexes in the same area can have vastly different values depending on their rental income.

The Professional Approach to Valuing Multifamily Properties

At Sage Real Estate, we use a comprehensive approach to value multifamily properties. Our process involves gathering detailed data and analyzing it to ensure an accurate valuation. Here’s how we do it:

1. Rent Roll Analysis

The first step in our process is reviewing the property’s rent roll. We look at gross income, rental rates, and whether rents are below market value. Higher rents often translate to higher property values, and we account for this when determining a property’s worth.

2. Comparable Sales

We handpick comparable properties in the area, focusing on those that recently sold. We go beyond online data, contacting the brokers involved in the sales to gather details about market demand, offer activity, and buyer interest.

3. Detailed Metrics

Our valuations include essential metrics such as:

  • Gross Rent Multiplier (GRM): The ratio of property value to gross rental income.
  • Capitalization Rate (Cap Rate): The rate of return based on income the property generates.
  • Price Per Door: The value of each unit within a multifamily property.
  • Price Per Square Foot: One of many metrics we consider, but not the only one.

4. Local Market Expertise

We analyze current market trends, recent transactions, and even the level of competition in the area. For example, if a property receives multiple offers within days, that demand significantly influences its value—something Zillow cannot capture.

Case Study: Why Professional Valuations Matter

One of the most striking examples of Zillow’s limitations comes from a property we recently sold in Long Beach. Here’s what happened:

  • The Property: A fourplex on Olive Avenue.
  • Zillow’s Estimate: $760,000.
  • Our Sale Price: $980,000.

Zillow’s valuation was 29% lower than the actual sale price. This discrepancy occurred because Zillow didn’t account for factors like rental income, market demand, and the property’s unique characteristics.

The Risks of Relying on Zillow

Using Zillow as your sole valuation tool can lead to costly mistakes:

1. Leaving Money on the Table

A low Zestimate may prompt you to sell below market value, costing you tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars.

2. Missed Opportunities

Without a professional valuation, you may not realize your property’s full potential, especially if rents could be increased or the property could be marketed differently.

3. Inaccurate Expectations

Zillow’s estimates can also be too high, leading to disappointment when the market doesn’t meet those expectations.

Why You Need a Multifamily Specialist

Valuing and selling multifamily properties requires specialized knowledge. Residential agents might be great at selling single-family homes, but they often lack the expertise to handle income-producing properties. When interviewing an agent, ask them:

  • What is the current cap rate in this market?
  • What is the gross rent multiplier for properties like mine?
  • How will you market my property to investors?

If they can’t answer these questions confidently, they’re likely not the right fit for your property.

Take Control of Your Property’s Value

If you own an income-producing property, don’t rely on Zillow to determine its worth. Instead, work with a real estate professional who understands the intricacies of multifamily properties and can help you maximize your return.

Contact us today for a free, professional market analysis of your property. We’ll provide a detailed breakdown of its value, including rental income potential, market trends, and comparable sales.

Don’t leave money on the table—get the accurate valuation you deserve.

Related Posts

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn